Health, Not Diets

Training and workshops in the Non-Diet Approach

Blog

Blog

But there are significant risks for mortality with increased BMI!!

Posted on January 12, 2017 at 11:50 PM

From a fellow dietitian:

"I do believe there are significant risks for mortality with increased BMI, irrespective of diet. I have seen studies supporting that, so I don’t think it’s a slam dunk for embracing any level of obesity. See the latest BMJ systematic review for example:

 

 

http://www.bmj.com/content/bmj/353/bmj.i2156.full.pdf"

My response:

My fingers get twitchy when I see this kind of research used to justify recommending weight loss, but I see it all the time and I think it's important to unpack the details.

 

The meta-analysis you've posted is a good one and can tell us many things. Mainly it shows that a group of larger people is, on average, likely to have a shorter lifespan than a group of smaller people. Interestingly, this one shows that smoking appears to be worse for you if you have a high BMI. The identification of the nadir of risk is great news for people who have a lower BMI relatively effortlessly despite living in an obesigenic environment that causes 2/3 of the population to creep up in weight over time (ie genetic jackpot). The recent influx of big BMI and mortality meta-analyses interestingly comes in response to Flegal's paper from 2013 which found that being overweight conferred the lowest risk of death in an NHANES dataset, thus suggesting that larger bodies might not be as bad as originally thought. Anyway, I digress. There are far more interesting things for dietitians in this study.

 

Firstly, where are our intentional weight losers (ie including our clients)? Well, we don't know. Unless they are running separate analysis for those who intentionally lost weight into a lower BMI category we cannot tell whether they have the same risks as so-called 'never-fat' people and so we cannot say that weight loss delivers on it's promise. This study found that using highest adult BMI when analysing mortality resulted in even lower risks for the lower BMI categories. So this might mean that all weight loss is bad, or it might mean that there are so few healthy people losing weight, keeping it off and not dying early that the disease-related weight loser stats drown them out. Think about that for a bit: there are more people actively dying from disease to the point that they are losing weight than there are people who have successfully, permanently lost weight. Probably a bit of both is true. Bottom line: population studies showing how bad obesity is do not justify recommending weight loss; they just show that being overweight/obese confers risk. They say nothing about the merits of no longer being obese or about the risks of becoming obese. Clearly there are also issues with the assumption that being, or not being, obese is completely within individual control. The answers to these questions are waiting to be discovered, hidden in datasets until such time that obesity researchers stop trying to be weight loss agents. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/nutrition-research-reviews/article/a-review-and-meta-analysis-of-the-effect-of-weight-loss-on-all-cause-mortality-risk/26226C6DF1BA32BEB00AAC87FC416667" target="_blank">Here is another paper looking at the mortality risks related to intentional weight loss (spoiler: overweight people who intentionally lost weight had an 11% increase in mortality). 

 

Secondly, the BMJ paper says that they did make adjustments for dietary quality and fitness. This sounds fabulous at face value, but I know this literature well and I wondered where on earth they found 230 BMI and mortality cohort studies that controlled for diet and exercise. So I nerded out in the supplementary material. Of the 230 studies included in the analysis, 59 controlled for physical activity (but not dietary factors), 10 controlled for dietary factors and physical activity, and 2 controlled for dietary factors (but not physical activity). People in these studies represented 7.7%, 3.8% and 0.062% of the total people studied respectively. I would not really consider that adequately controlled for food and fitness factors.

 

Accepting the findings of this paper, and those like it that do not properly adjust for food and fitness, means essentially that we are accepting that nourishment and fitness make no difference to mortality. Sedentary people with poor diets are lumped in with fit people with great diets within each of the BMI categories. Most of the studies included did not adjust for SES either. Does that seem fair or accurate? It makes a mockery of the work that we do every day to move people towards a healthier lifestyle. BMI does not measure dietary quality or fitness; we need to insist that studies do not continue to conflate BMI with health behaviours and actually measure the behaviours as endpoints instead. Studies that look at health behaviours independently of BMI find consistently that behaviours do make a difference to morbidity and mortality regardless of weight. Even if dietitians can't quite accept the futility of intentional weight loss, it might be helpful to think of focussing on health behaviours instead of weight as a form of damage control.

 

I used to do weight loss counselling in the early days of having my private practice. They would lose weight and I would feel great, they would feel great; it was celebration time. On the less frequent occasion of a client actually reaching their goal weight I had a spring in my step for days. It confirmed to me at the time that I must be a good dietitian and that dietetics really did have the key to lasting weight loss. I believed that those who weren't losing weight weren't following my plan or trying hard enough, so it was easy to label it as an adherence/noncompliance problem, not an issue with the way we were doing things in dietetics.

 

Becoming a researcher and working in academia involved the humbling process of accepting that my experiences and beliefs were not representative. Only seeing the 'honeymoon' phase of weight loss and devaluing the importance of my clients' previous (failed) weight loss attempts had lead me to have a distorted view of the effectiveness of dietetic counselling for weight loss. Unless a dietitian is following all of their clients for 5+ years it is likely that they suffer this same confirmation bias. In the absence of good quality research showing the 5 year outcomes of dietitian-delivered, individualised weight loss counselling, we have to accept that we are probably the same or worse than the well-funded, multidisciplinary, beautifully designed weight loss studies described in the literature which were used by the NHMRC in their review to conclude that long-term weight loss for the majority of people is unattainable.



 

 


 

Categories: HAES, Dietitian, Research

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

6864 Comments

Reply Elizabeth McGlone
1:03 PM on July 2, 2017 
Thanks for the informative article. I am starting to work on a obesity prevention project with children and wondered if ?waist circumference? could also be a good measure for children as well.

Also if it?s possible could you provide a few citations for these types of article? They?d be helpful those who?d like to do some further reading.

Thanks again!
Reply Custom dissertation writing service
12:07 AM on December 16, 2017 
Thanks for sharing this article. Really glad to read this article and I will refer this site to my friends.Nice post , much interesting . thank you for your post . Visit here (https://customedwriting.com)keep up the good work.I really admire your work and i hope in future i will return for more info. like this one.
Reply alia
2:47 AM on August 11, 2018 
Reply Mike
11:36 AM on August 11, 2018 
Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an really long comment but
go PhenQ http://www.guideonhcgdrops.com/phenq-review.html
Reply michaelcarr
4:17 PM on April 17, 2020 
You need to clearly comprehend what worksheets would be useful for you in this very case.
Reply java letter
7:31 AM on April 22, 2020 
All these documents can help you create a unique solution, java letter that is completely suitable for you and can guarantee a good result.
Reply kyrie 5 spongebob
7:00 PM on July 13, 2020 
Thanks so much for giving everyone such a breathtaking chance to read articles and blog posts from this blog. It really is very nice and as well , full of amusement for me and my office peers to visit your blog not less than three times in 7 days to read through the fresh items you have. And of course, I am also always astounded considering the special suggestions you give. Certain 4 areas on this page are clearly the most effective we have ever had.
kyrie 5 spongebob http://www.kyrie5spongebob.us
Reply jordan shoes
1:06 PM on July 14, 2020 
I and my buddies were found to be studying the best hints found on the website while all of a sudden got a terrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to the website owner for those secrets. My young men happened to be so thrilled to learn them and have truly been having fun with them. I appreciate you for being simply accommodating and also for finding varieties of incredibly good themes most people are really desirous to be aware of. My very own sincere regret for not expressing appreciation to earlier.
jordan shoes http://www.jordanshoes.us
Reply supreme hoodie
7:27 PM on July 16, 2020 
Thank you so much for providing individuals with remarkably brilliant chance to read articles and blog posts from here. It really is very nice and packed with a lot of fun for me and my office friends to search your web site at a minimum three times in 7 days to study the new tips you have got. And definitely, we are at all times fulfilled with the great tactics you serve. Selected 1 facts in this posting are definitely the simplest I've had.
supreme hoodie http://www.supremeshoodie.com
Reply curry 7 shoes
1:33 PM on July 17, 2020 
I must express thanks to you for rescuing me from this particular situation. As a result of surfing around through the the web and finding notions which were not powerful, I assumed my life was over. Living without the presence of solutions to the problems you have resolved all through your main short post is a critical case, as well as the kind that would have in a negative way damaged my career if I hadn't noticed your web page. Your actual skills and kindness in controlling a lot of things was precious. I am not sure what I would've done if I hadn't discovered such a thing like this. I can also at this time relish my future. Thanks so much for your professional and results-oriented guide. I won't be reluctant to refer the website to any person who should get direction on this situation.
curry 7 shoes http://www.curry7.us
Reply yeezys
4:52 PM on July 20, 2020 
A lot of thanks for all your work on this website. My mom really loves engaging in internet research and it is simple to grasp why. Almost all know all concerning the lively way you make very helpful techniques through the web site and as well invigorate participation from visitors about this point and our own daughter is truly becoming educated a great deal. Take advantage of the remaining portion of the new year. You are always performing a powerful job.
yeezys http://www.yeezysus.com
Reply cheap jordans
4:34 AM on July 21, 2020 
I truly wanted to develop a small message in order to say thanks to you for all of the fantastic guides you are giving out on this site. My rather long internet search has at the end been rewarded with incredibly good strategies to talk about with my relatives. I 'd point out that we visitors are undeniably fortunate to exist in a fabulous place with many awesome professionals with helpful pointers. I feel very fortunate to have discovered your web pages and look forward to so many more thrilling times reading here. Thanks a lot again for everything.
cheap jordans http://www.shoesjordan.us.com
Reply curry shoes
6:45 PM on July 23, 2020 
My spouse and i have been now delighted Louis could round up his web research through the precious recommendations he gained through your site. It is now and again perplexing just to happen to be offering instructions that other folks have been making money from. Therefore we discover we've got the website owner to thank because of that. These illustrations you have made, the straightforward site menu, the relationships you assist to promote - it is all powerful, and it's really aiding our son and our family reckon that that matter is thrilling, and that is extraordinarily indispensable. Thanks for the whole thing!
curry shoes http://www.curry6shoes.us
Reply adidas yeezy
1:42 PM on July 24, 2020 
I wish to express my passion for your kindness supporting people who have the need for assistance with your subject matter. Your real commitment to getting the solution all around had become definitely powerful and has enabled many people like me to achieve their endeavors. The useful guide denotes a lot a person like me and especially to my fellow workers. With thanks; from everyone of us.
adidas yeezy http://www.yeezy-shoes.us.org
Reply ilasaxugivp
4:42 AM on July 25, 2020 
http://mewkid.net/when-is-xuxlya/ - Amoxicillin 500mg Capsules Buy Amoxicillin Online rzl.lppn.healthnotdiets.com.rdf.kv http://mewkid.net/when-is-xuxlya/
Reply ozakuguxacu
5:14 AM on July 25, 2020 
http://mewkid.net/when-is-xuxlya/ - Amoxicillin 500mg Buy Amoxicillin lbw.wect.healthnotdiets.com.wna.nq http://mewkid.net/when-is-xuxlya/
Reply evoxaceberoy
5:43 AM on July 25, 2020 
http://mewkid.net/when-is-xuxlya/ - Amoxicillin 500mg Capsules Amoxicillin Without Prescription atk.cqqu.healthnotdiets.com.khn.uf http://mewkid.net/when-is-xuxlya/
Reply ipofaicas
5:50 AM on July 25, 2020 
In kts.jskv.healthnotdiets.com.fbd.xm spinocerebellar mutations [URL=http://homemenderinc.com/item/p-force-fort/ - p force fort[/URL - [URL=http://shaunajmiller.com/xalatan/ - buy xalatan online[/URL - xalatan [URL=http://psuclubswim.com/acetaminophen/ - acetaminophen commercial[/URL - [URL=http://shaunajmiller.com/nicardia-retard-cd/ - where to buy nicardia retard cd online[/URL - [URL=http://gunde1resim.com/generic-levitra-20mg/ - levitra vardenafil[/URL - [URL=http://timoc.org/prednisone/ - prednisone[/URL - [URL=http://psuclubswim.com/amitone/ - amitone online no script[/URL - [URL=http://homemenderinc.com/item/duetact/ - duetact[/URL - generic duetact tablets [URL=http://aestheticio.com/super-p-force-in-usa/ - generic for super p force[/URL - [URL=http://seoseekho.com/mycelex-g/ - mycelex g price at walmart[/URL - [URL=http://historicgrandhotels.com/human-growth-agent/ - human growth agent buy in canada[/URL - human growth agent [URL=http://tammymaltby.com/lamivudin/ - buy lamivudin uk[/URL - [URL=http://simpletahoeweddings.com/cialis-light-pack-60/ - prices for cialis light pack 60[/URL - [URL=http://parentswithangst.com/flagyl/ - metronidazole 500 mg[/URL - [URL=http://goodroofcompany.com/allopurinol/ - allopurinol price at walmart[/URL - vacuum kin brunt p force fort prices for xalatan generic xalatan canada pharmacy acetaminophen where to buy nicardia retard cd online levitra mg 20 purchase prednisone amitone cheap generic duetact at walmart generic super p force from india mycelex g human growth agent lamivudin cialis light pack 60 price at walmart flagyl metronidazole purchase allopurinol online satisfy guarding recent http://homemenderinc.com/item/p-force-fort/ p force fort for sale overnight http://shaunajmiller.com/xalatan/ xalatan http://psuclubswim.com/acetaminophen/ acetaminophen pills http://shaunajmiller.com/nicardia-retard-cd/ generic nicardia retard cd http://gunde1resim.com/generic-levitra-20mg/ levitra 20 mg cheapest price http://timoc.org/prednisone/ prednisone 20 mg http://psuclubswim.com/amitone/ amitone cheap http://homemenderinc.com/item/duetact/ duetact without dr prescription http://aestheticio.com/super-p-force-in-usa/ generic super p force online http://seoseekho.com/mycelex-g/ generic mycelex g uk http://historicgrandhotels.com/human-growth-agent/ human growth agent walmart price http://tammymaltby.com/lamivudin/ lamivudin without pres http://simpletahoeweddings.com/cialis-light-pack-60/ prices for cialis light pack 60 http://parentswithangst.com/flagyl/ metronidazole 500mg http://goodroofcompany.com/allopurinol/ allopurinol online canada green-yellow threatening cannula, control.
Reply oxocepocuzaj
5:50 AM on July 25, 2020 
Wartenberg's ixs.eolg.healthnotdiets.com.wxa.lg threshold, [URL=http://lokcal.org/item/neem/ - neem best price usa[/URL - [URL=http://biblebaptistny.org/nexium/ - nexium generic[/URL - [URL=http://lokcal.org/item/breast-success/ - breast success[/URL - [URL=http://historicgrandhotels.com/cialis-oral-jelly/ - cialis oral jelly non generic[/URL - [URL=http://casatheodoro.com/item/duzela/ - canada duzela[/URL - buy duzela uk [URL=http://goodroofcompany.com/testosterone-gel/ - testosterone gel from india[/URL - [URL=http://gghoops.com/relipoietin/ - generic relipoietin[/URL - [URL=http://theriversidegrove.com/item/budez-cr/ - budez cr canadian pharmacy[/URL - [URL=http://homeairconditioningoutlet.com/yaz/ - yaz prices[/URL - [URL=http://eastoftherivertx.com/nootropil/ - buying nootropil[/URL - [URL=http://themusicianschoice.net/cialis-gout/ - cialis apteka[/URL - [URL=http://tofupost.com/cialis-40mg/ - generico cialis[/URL - [URL=http://eastoftherivertx.com/xeloda/ - low cost xeloda[/URL - [URL=http://androidforacademics.com/product/viramune/ - buy cheap viramune[/URL - [URL=http://simpletahoeweddings.com/hydrocl/ - hydrocl[/URL - gestures guts strengthens neem overnight cheap nexium breast success without a prescription overnight cialis oral jelly duzela online testosterone gel no prescription relipoietin cheap budez cr cheap yaz pills buy nootropil online canada buying nootropil online snl cialis cialis 20mg original xeloda on internet low cost viramune hydrocl online pharmacy damaged, conservatively everything http://lokcal.org/item/neem/ neem overnight http://biblebaptistny.org/nexium/ buy generic nexium http://lokcal.org/item/breast-success/ generic breast success in canada http://historicgrandhotels.com/cialis-oral-jelly/ low price cialis oral jelly http://casatheodoro.com/item/duzela/ duzela http://goodroofcompany.com/testosterone-gel/ testosterone gel walmart price http://gghoops.com/relipoietin/ relipoietin http://theriversidegrove.com/item/budez-cr/ cheap budez cr http://homeairconditioningoutlet.com/yaz/ yaz from canada http://eastoftherivertx.com/nootropil/ nootropil http://themusicianschoice.net/cialis-gout/ levitra viagra cialis compare http://tofupost.com/cialis-40mg/ cialis hqmedi http://eastoftherivertx.com/xeloda/ xeloda side effect testimonials http://androidforacademics.com/product/viramune/ viramune without an rx http://simpletahoeweddings.com/hydrocl/ generic hydrocl from india compensation, adaptations.
Reply ubermasu
6:13 AM on July 25, 2020 
In hxg.rzil.healthnotdiets.com.ygt.cw dedicated [URL=http://casatheodoro.com/item/kenacort-injection/ - kenacort injection brand[/URL - [URL=http://shaunajmiller.com/hucog-5000-hp/ - hucog 5000 hp commercial[/URL - [URL=http://androidforacademics.com/product/medex/ - canadian medex[/URL - medex.com [URL=http://takara-ramen.com/drugs/hytrin/ - generic hytrin uk[/URL - [URL=http://historicgrandhotels.com/keflex/ - keflex without prescription[/URL - [URL=http://casatheodoro.com/item/rizact/ - lowest price for rizact[/URL - [URL=http://heavenlyhappyhour.com/vigrx/ - vigrx[/URL - [URL=http://homemenderinc.com/item/hydrazide/ - hydrazide[/URL - [URL=http://americanartgalleryandgifts.com/viagra-with-fluoxetine
/ - viagra with fluoxetine without a prescription[/URL - [URL=http://growingmypennies.com/acetaminophen/ - acetaminophen without dr prescription[/URL - [URL=http://scoutcampreviews.com/ditropan/ - ditropan[/URL - [URL=http://reubendangoor.com/product/cheap-cialis/ - u 15640 cialis[/URL - [URL=http://fbwhatsapquotes.com/canadian-pharmacy-price/ - canadian pharmacy price[/URL - [URL=http://casatheodoro.com/item/cartidin/ - online cartidin no prescription[/URL - [URL=http://eastoftherivertx.com/mintop-forte-foam/ - mintop forte foam best price usa[/URL - gets recreate speed canada kenacort injection generic hucog 5000 hp from canada buy medex online hytrin price at walmart purchase keflex online rizact generic canada vigrx hydrazide viagra with fluoxetine for sale acetaminophen ditropan buy in canada cialis in frankreich pharmacy canadian pharmacy price www.cartidin.com mintop forte foam tool, http://casatheodoro.com/item/kenacort-injection/ kenacort injection http://shaunajmiller.com/hucog-5000-hp/ hucog 5000 hp online pharmacy http://androidforacademics.com/product/medex/ medex capsules http://takara-ramen.com/drugs/hytrin/ www.hytrin.com http://historicgrandhotels.com/keflex/ keflex http://casatheodoro.com/item/rizact/ lowest price for rizact rizact without dr prescription http://heavenlyhappyhour.com/vigrx/ cheap vigrx http://homemenderinc.com/item/hydrazide/ hydrazide buy in canada http://americanartgalleryandgifts.com/viagra-with-fluoxetine/ viagra with fluoxetine no prescription http://growingmypennies.com/acetaminophen/ acetaminophen http://scoutcampreviews.com/ditropan/ buy ditropan online http://reubendangoor.com/product/cheap-cialis/ tadalafil generic best prices http://fbwhatsapquotes.com/canadian-pharmacy-price/ canada pharmacy online no script http://casatheodoro.com/item/cartidin/ cartidin online cartidin no prescription http://eastoftherivertx.com/mintop-forte-foam/ mintop forte foam generic pills absoption microbiologist; hour.